We are now over half way through Middlemarch in my course on the later 19th-century novel: this is our last week working on it, and also my last week ever of leading class discussion of this novel which in so many ways has defined my academic career. I have written so often about Middlemarch, and about teaching Middlemarch, that it is hard to know what more to say about it at this point.
Here’s something: I had planned to dedicate yesterday’s class primarily to discussion of Bulstrode–his morally dubious past, his ultimately futile attempts to suppress it, the murky question of his liability for Raffles’s death (“And who could say that the death of Raffles had been hastened?” as the narrator observes, and yet also, “intention was everything in the question of right and wrong”). We did get to these issues eventually, but we got to them later than I’d intended because as I was rehearsing the problems in Lydgate and Rosamond’s marriage on the way to the moment when Lydgate asks Bulstrode for a loan, hands started going up: people wanted to talk about Rosamond–both her conduct and character and the narrator’s treatment of her, which as has often been noticed, is conspicuously less forgiving than the narrator’s treatment of other arguably much less forgivable characters.
As you might expect, I was thrilled. Not only is this an important and complicated discussion to have in itself, but also it was such a welcome sign of genuine engagement. Reading Middlemarch is a big job, especially in the middle of term, and it can sometimes feel like it’s too much, that however good my and their intentions, students get bogged down in it. The last time I assigned it in this course, I staged an ‘intervention’ at one point because the class’s energy seemed so low. Was it, really? It can be so hard to tell: not all engagement is loudly vocal, and that was the class that (it turned out) affected one student so much that a year or so later he said that he had thought about Middlemarch pretty much every day since. But yesterday I eventually had to deliberately wind down the Rosamond debate, partly so we could get in some time on Bulstrode and Raffles and partly because we haven’t actually read to the end of the novel yet and in tomorrow’s class we can come back to Rosamond by way of the thrilling encounter between her and Dorothea in Chapter 81. Dorothea is kinder to Rosamond than the narrator: she bathes Rosamond in the light of her own ardent generosity, whereas the narrator is more like the rest of us imperfect beings, trying diligently to do the moral work of sympathy but finding it pretty hard work at times!
There have been other good signs–in hallway chats and office hours, for instance–that for a number of students this year, reading Middlemarch is proving as stimulating and rewarding as any teacher could hope. This is lovely and also, inevitably, a bit melancholy. A few years ago a student, now a good friend, gave me a mug inscribed with the beautiful final lines of Middlemarch. Another former student has the word “ardent” tattooed on her wrist. There is comfort to be had in evidence like this of my having made a difference, that having done this work for so long with so many students (how many, over 32 years? many hundreds, certainly) has had an “incalculably diffusive” effect that in its own quiet way contributes to the “growing good of the world.”
I hope that doesn’t sound grandiose. The most comforting idea in Middlemarch is surely that small efforts do matter. I have never had dramatic aspirations for my academic work or my pedagogy: some people seem to imagine that our efforts as literary scholars and teachers can or should have a more revolutionary, a more explicitly political, impetus or result. It has always seemed to me that if you really want to change the world, literary studies is at any rate not the most obvious way to go about it, and maybe some of the inflated rhetoric about its radicalism reflects some anxiety about that reality. Ideas do matter, though, and so do the stories we tell about the world, and the ways we think about it and about ourselves in it. I think often of Ishiguro’s idea that novels are a kind of invitation: “in the end, stories are about one person saying to another: This is the way it feels to me. Can you understand what I’m saying? Does it also feel this way to you?” I also think often of Anthony Trollope’s remark that “no man … can work long at any trade without being brought to consider much whether that which he is doing daily tends to evil or to good.” “I have convinced myself,” I wrote in a conference paper presented two decades ago,
that by teaching my students about George Eliot, by encouraging (OK, requiring) them to read her novels, by inviting them to enter her godless world and reflect on the premises of her sympathetic morality, I contribute in my own small way to “widening the skirts of light and making the struggle with darkness narrower.”
As Dorothea says, “I have a belief of my own, and it comforts me.” This is my comforting belief about the “trade” I have worked at for so long–but it won’t entirely console me when I am no longer in the room for these conversations.


You’ve expressed beautifully my own feelings on retiring from teaching literature a few years ago.
LikeLike
So many mixed emotions, right? It’s not as if I will miss marking exams on weekends or doing committee work. 🙂
LikeLike
I can honestly say I don’t miss commuting (especially now that my bus runs through the pit of massive road work) and much about marking and planning and fretting over whether there’d be work next year (that question was finally answered negatively, thanks to massive budget cuts). But I miss lecturing; I miss discussion; I miss students emailing me or running up to my desk to say how much they loved a text we were doing.
LikeLike