Novel Readings 2014

I didn’t realize what a good reading year 2014 was until I started going back through my blog posts. I think the slump I fell into in the late fall unfairly cast its shadow back over the rest of the year!


Book of the Year: The high point of my reading in 2014 would have to be Dorothy Dunnett’s King Hereafter. It wasn’t the easiest book to get through, but I was completely engrossed by the end. It doesn’t have the grand melodrama of the Lymond books I have loved so long, but it has both an intellectual reach and an emotional depth that are rare to find together. Dunnett has the special gift (shared by A. S. Byatt and Hilary Mantel) of making her historical research abundantly manifest without wearing us down with it.

Other novels I’m especially glad to have read and written about:

Another Dunnett novel is high up on this list: I finally read Niccolo Rising, and while it did not sweep me away the way King Hereafter did, my trust in Dunnett (and in the many readers who have recommended this series — some of whom regard it even more highly than the Lymond chronicles!) helped me press on through what seemed like a slow beginning (one I had in fact tried two or three times before, only to stall) — until this time I eventually found I was thoroughly interested in how things were developing. I’ve got the next two  lined up to read in 2015.

I relished both novels I read this year by Daphne du Maurier. I can’t imagine that romantic suspense gets any better than Jamaica Inn (which was a selection for both of my book clubs), and My Cousin Rachel is more subtle but every bit as deliciously twisty.

Also twisty, if not altogether delicious: Vikram Chandra’s Sacred Games. I didn’t end up loving it, but I loved parts of it, and since I’ve owned it for ages it feels very good to have read it at long (long) last.

helprinOne novel I did love – in a headlong, romantic, uncharacteristically uncritical way – was Mark Helprin’s In Sunlight and In Shadow. It’s such a heartfelt book I think you have to hang up your cynicism at the door or not even bother. If you can accept it on its own terms, though, it’s just a really, really beautiful book. And yet I’m still hesitant about reading Winter’s Tale . . .

The year’s most strange and memorable book for me was Lady Chatterley’s LoverI still hardly know what I think about this book! But for sheer provocation (mental, not sensual – it’s a weirdly unsexy book, if you ask me), it had no real competition.

Another book that really made me think, but that I enjoyed much more, was Howards End. Like Lady Chatterley, this book made me feel both confused and frustrated at times as I tried to figure out what its different aspects meant or added up to. Unlike Lady Chatterley, however, Howards End is one I look forward to revisiting, for another chance to make sense of it but also just to appreciate it again.

behaSometimes the whole is more than the sum of its parts: that’s what I concluded as I read Christopher Beha’s What Happened to Sophie Wilder and Graham Greene’s The End of the Affair in close proximity. They are books in conversation with each other, and while neither of them is likely to become a personal favorite of mine, both on their own and together they really made me think — about fiction, about characters, about love, about religion.

I really liked Colum McCann’s Let the Great World Spin. And then, almost as much as I enjoyed the book, if in a different way, I appreciated the conversation it started, first in my head then in the comments to my post, about why we like some books and not others, or why others don’t like books we love and vice versa.

Finally, I made my belated acquaintance with Brother Cadfael this year, with the first of Ellis Peters’s medieval mysteries, A Morbid Taste for Bones. I was fortunate enough to inherit the complete run of the series; I’m hoarding the rest for the dreary snow-bound days I know are sure to come this winter. What could be more comforting when a blizzard rages than hot chocolate, biscuits, and books this deft and smart?

Memorable Non-Fiction

gourevitchI read a lot more fiction than non-fiction, but I read three stunning and memorable works of non-fiction in 2014: Sonali Deraniyagala’s heartbreaking Wave, Philip Gourevitch’s We Wish to Inform You That Tomorrow We Will Be Killed With Our Families, and Edmund de Waal’s The Hare with Amber Eyes. All deal with unspeakable tragedies, but all do so with such intelligence and care that the results, though rarely uplifting in any simple way, are remarkably beautiful, and sometimes even hopeful.

Rebecca Mead’s My Life in Middlemarch also deserves a mention here. As some of you know, I approached it with skepticism, because I am wary of criticism that subordinates works of great literature to our own petty private lives. I didn’t much like the New Yorker essay that was Mead’s trial balloon for this project, but the book won me over with its lovely writing, tender reminiscences, and thoughtful attention to Middlemarch as a book that changes and grows with its readers.

The Low Point

The only book I actively disliked this year was Elena Ferrante’s The Days of Abandonment. I can’t say for sure that it’s a bad novel, but it is certainly a very unpleasant one, and I’ll say just one more time (in 2014, anyway) that I think people effuse about Ferrante because she offers them something they are looking for from a woman writer, not because her novels are self-evidently brilliant. Is The Days of Abandonment “honest,” as critics keep insisting? Perhaps, though what that means applied to a work of fiction I’m not really sure. But the harsh truth it’s taken to trade in isn’t the whole truth, and just because something is or feels raw doesn’t necessarily mean it’s artistic.

Happy New Year!

Thank you as always to everyone who read and commented on Novel Readings in 2014. Special thanks as well to the many bloggers and tweeters who have engaged, interested, and encouraged me this year — it is such a pleasure knowing you all and talking about books (and so much else) with you every day.

Some of the books I’m looking forward to reading in 2015:



11 thoughts on “Novel Readings 2014

  1. Teresa December 31, 2014 / 8:43 pm

    Hooray for King Hereafter! And Niccolo! And Daphne du Maurier! You really did have a great reading year, with those four books.

    And I love your point about the conversation making the reading of a book more rewarding. It’s one of the reasons I keep plugging away at the blog.


  2. Bill from PA December 31, 2014 / 9:08 pm

    Rohan, since you’re thinking about Winter’s Tale, have you read John Crowley’s excellent fantasy Little, Big? I remember that at the time Winter’s Tale was first published my friends who were into SF / Fantasy felt that the Helprin book, which came out about a year or so after the Crowley, was a pale shadow of the earlier book. On their recommendation I read the Crowley and found it very good; I was still considering reading the Helprin when he published an article in the NYT Magazine advocating nuclear proliferation (“Drawing The Line In Europe: The Case For Missile Deployment.” New York Times Magazine, 4 December 1983: 52-64) which pretty much put him beyond the pale for me.
    Note that I had intended to include a link to Helprin’s nuclear missile article since the Times supposedly has its full archives on line, but it seems some current day Winston Smith has been at work and the article never shows up in any archival search, though some letters (paywall may apply) remain behind .


    • Rohan January 2, 2015 / 11:49 am

      I haven’t read Little, Bit (I read almost no ‘fantasy’) but I saw it come up in your discussion with Dorian and wondered about it. I don’t know anything about Helprin outside of his books: sounds like I might prefer to keep it that way.


    • Amateur Reader (Tom) January 5, 2015 / 1:31 am

      For some reason, don’t ask me why, I have agreed to a Little, Big readalong in April. It is a wonderful and unusual book. How it fits into anything you, or I, am up to now, that escapes me.


  3. Rebecca H. December 31, 2014 / 9:41 pm

    There’s a lot here I’m going to keep in the back of my mind to explore on my own when the time is right, including Dorothy Dunnett and the Helprin. And The Hare with the Amber Eyes. I’m glad you came to admire the Mead, as it makes me feel better about liking it so much. I read Days of Abandonment this year too, and it left me feeling bewildered; I’m curious to see how similar or not My Brilliant Friend is. Days of Abandonment was a tough book! Anyway, have a great 2015.


    • Rohan January 2, 2015 / 11:50 am

      Thanks, Rebecca – you too! My Brilliant Friend is much tamer, though it’s certainly not a sentimental portrait of either their community or their friendship.


  4. Colleen January 1, 2015 / 4:08 pm

    I’m so glad you enjoyed your first Cadfael novel! I was just thinking this morning how sad I am to not have any more of them to look forward to. I’ve got Peters’s Brothers of Gwynedd quartet ready to be read but I think I need to give it more time; I fear I’m still yearning too specifically for my beloved monastic sleuth.

    You’ve reminded me (again) that I really need to do myself the favour of reading Dunnett and du Maurier…

    Looking forward to reading about your 2015!


  5. Keira Soleore January 2, 2015 / 3:56 pm

    Commenting here for the first time. I enjoyed reading your list of books. Dorothy Dunnett was the high point of my reading year, too. The Game of Kings, the first of her Lymonds, was my first book by her, and I was completely blown away by it. I read it twice, listened to the audiobook, and also read a companion guide to it.

    Over the years, I have forgotten about Daphne du Maurier. This is a good reminder to get back to her.

    Have you seen Howards End by Merchant Ivory? I really enjoyed the movie.


    • Rohan Maitzen January 2, 2015 / 7:19 pm

      Hi, Keira! I remember vividly the first time I read The Game of Kings — I’m not sure I actually breathed during the whole of the climactic duel with Richard, and then the twists and turns of the trial, and the game of cards that wins the crucial evidence … yes, “blown away” is exactly right.

      I think I must have seen the movie of Howards End back when it came out, because I used to see every Merchant-Ivory adpatation, but I have absolutely no memory of it. We’ve been planning to rent it this holiday but haven’t got around to it! Too much tempting British TV on Netflix…


  6. Stefanie January 2, 2015 / 4:01 pm

    A good year for sure! And it looks like good things ahead in 2015. Happy New Year!


    • Rohan Maitzen January 2, 2015 / 7:20 pm

      Thanks, Stefanie! I’ve started on my 2015 books and so far, so good.


Leave a Reply to Rohan Maitzen Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.